Cutting Down Medical Gibberish: FDA Concerns
Yen-Anh Bui, PharmD Candidate 2004
Virginia Commonwealth University School of Pharmacy, Richmond,
VA
Prepared during Consumer Health Information Corporation Clerkship
McLean,
VA
"DYSPHAGIA, ERUCTATION,
MYALGIA, DYSMENORRHEA"
“What do they all mean?”
my mother asked me as she points to a section called “Brief
Summary of Prescribing Information” in the February 2004
issue of Reader’s Digest magazine.
“It took me an hour, one magnifying
glass and a medical dictionary to read just one page and I still
don’t know what they’re talking about!” Frustrated,
she looked at me, “You’re in pharmacy school. Maybe
you can understand this language better. This was a waste of my
time!”
I picked up the magazine as I watched my
mother walk away. The ad was for Celebrex® (celecoxib), a
medicine used to treat pain and swelling. The heading, “One
pill. 24 hours. If the joint pain of osteoarthritis is
holding you back, ask your doctor about Celebrex®.”
appeared boldly on top.
Then I turned to the back of the ad to
read the medicine information called the “Brief Summary”
that my mother was having trouble understanding. The page was
filled with tiny print letters and hard medical words like those
above. A few minutes into reading the page, I realized the reason
for my mother’s frustration.
As a pharmacist, my first thoughts were:
- There must be a better way to explain this information.
- How does anyone find this information useful if they can’t
understand it?
- Why do drug companies put this technical information on the
back of Direct-To-Consumer ads?
In the search for the answers, I turned to the
Food and Drug Administration.
FDA’s guidelines
The FDA requires that drug companies provide consumers with risks
and benefits information with every drug ad. Drug companies have
a choice. They can either print the FDA-approved Brief Summary
(developed for health professionals) or a FDA-approved Patient
Package Insert (PPI) (developed for consumers) on the back of
each drug ad.
The Pitfalls of the Brief Summary from
the Consumer’s View
When a prescription drug is approved by FDA, the company must
develop a Brief Summary that contains technical information about
the drug for doctors, pharmacists and other health professionals.
It was never intended to be given to patients.
Many critics say the Brief Summary contains no
useful information for consumers. A person needs some medical
background to understand it. For example, in 2002, FDA did a survey
of consumers and found that about 73% of people read little or
none of this Brief Summary. This is a serious problem since many
consumers are relying on this information to determine whether
they want to ask their doctor about the drug being advertised.
So why do drug companies still use Brief Summaries
in their ads? One reason is that the Brief Summary has already
been approved by FDA and it is cheaper to use this document rather
than develop one in language that patients can understand. Some
companies used to be concerned that it was risky to select important
information and translate it for consumers. However, the courts
are starting to challenge this and warning that it is too risky
for consumers to receive drug information they cannot understand.
Consumers need drug information they
can understand!
More and more drug companies are convinced that consumers need
information about their medicines in language they can understand.
Drug companies are not required to have PPIs. However, some companies
have developed PPIs to replace Brief Summaries because they know
that it is important to provide information that consumers can
understand. They are willing to invest the time and money it takes
to develop a Patient Package Insert (PPI) and get FDA to approve
its use as a replacement for the Brief Summary in DTC ads.
In the long run, it is very important to a drug
company that people taking their medicines know how to manage
them safely and wisely. This means they need to understand how
to take the medicine, what to tell the doctor, the common side
effects and what to do if they happen, what to do if an overdose
is taken, and how to know if the drug is working as it should.
How do I know which drug ad has a PPI?
You can tell just by looking at how it is written. If it is written
in language that a non-medical person can understand, it is probably
a PPI. You can also visit a drug company’s website or call
the 800 number that is often listed on the front of the ad and
ask for a copy if available.
What is the FDA doing to make sure consumers
receive information they can understand?
On February 4th 2004, the FDA issued new guidelines for drug companies
to improve their Brief Summaries. Companies are encouraged to
make information clear and easy to understand. Only the most important
information should be provided. “Less is more for the consumers,”
said FDA Commissioner, Mark McClellan. He also believes information
for consumers should be explained in language that is easy to
read and understand.
What can I do to make sure I understand
information about my medicine?
- When you come across something you don’t understand
in a drug ad, write it down
or draw a circle around it.
- Ask your doctor or pharmacist to explain this information
to you.
- Every drug has side effects. It’s important to know
what they are. If you do not understand any of the side effects
listed in the Brief Summary, ask your doctor or pharmacist to
explain and describe these side effects to you. Do not leave
until you fully understand the information.
- Write down the information.
- Some side effects are more dangerous than others. Ask your
doctor or pharmacist which side effects you should be most concerned
about.
- Report any side effects that bother you to your pharmacist
and doctor.
- The advertised drug is not for everyone. Discuss with your
doctor if the medicine is right for you. Make sure you understand
how to take your medicine correctly.
The FDA and many drug companies have tried to
improve the information that we get about our medicines. But we
can help by taking an active role and seeking answers for ourselves.
Take control of your health and ask questions until you understand
the information that is given to you.
© 2004 Consumer Health Information Corporation. All rights reserved.

|